Intellectual ventures told us if we wanted to understand what the company was all about, we should talk to this inventor it had helped out, a patent holder named chris crawford. Intellectual ventures iv, the worlds largest patentlicensing. Apr 15, 2017 a patent troll is a derogatory term used to describe the use of patent infringement claims to win court judgments for profit or to stifle competition. Intellectual ventures got 90% of ongoing profits even after selling patent. Although the nif for its part has won itself laurels around the country, intellectual ventures has been condemned by some for following the very same business model. Colbert report intellectual ventures, the patent holding company founded by exmicrosoft cto nathan myhrvold, is widely accused of being a patent troll a company that exists mainly to extract. Intellectual ventures shows patent troll like ambitions. Dec 20, 2012 back in 2010, we wrote about a report suggesting that intellectual ventures was using somewhere around shell companies to hide many of its patent shakedown attempts. Citing the states consumer protection act, sorrell is suing notorious patent troll mphj technology investments, alleging that it routinely targets small companies and some nonprofits. Intellectual ventures is an american private company that centers on the development and. Like us, quinn agrees that there is indeed a problem with bad actors in. Today national public radio ran a story on software patents titled when patents attack. World patent marketing supports inventors by fighting patent troll scams and intellectual property fraud adam carolla settles with podcasting patent troll.
It doesnt delay your flight like united, buffer your movie stream like comcast, or shellac your shrimp with oil like bp. Npr reporter laura sydell and this american life producerplanet money. A patent troll is a company that exploits existing structural issues within the u. Featured prominently in this piece was intellectual ventures, a company that has amassed a significant patent portfolio. Planet money why would a company rent an office in a tiny town in east texas, put a nameplate on the door, and leave it completely empty. Techdirt and other technology blogs have written about. Is nate up to some old tricks in playing the patent troll issue on both sides of the fence or what. It doesnt delay your flight like united, buffer your movie. Nathan myhrvold and other executives at the controversial company say critics simply dont understand what theyre doing. This american life, an entertaining weekly npr news feature, cannot resist using illdefined trolls as a basis to attack the patent system. It seems to be set up to help defend its investors against socalled patent trolls, enterprising patent lawyers and small companies that sue but have few or no products for sale. In 2000, he founded a company called intellectual ventures, which he calls a.
Holma, an animalnutrition expert, had 20 years earlier developed a cow feed that increased the fat content of their milk. The names of about 2,000 alleged patent trolls have been exposed by legal research site plainsite this week. How hightech banks are fighting back against patent trolls. Back in 2011, intellectual ventures fired off a patent infringement complaint against motorola mobility in the district of delaware. Aug 04, 2011 later, detkin cofounded intellectual ventures, which some characterize as patent troll as revealed in this npr report, when patents attack, iv is apparently closely connected with lodsys, the patent troll suing ios developers for patent infringement. Intellectual ventures is one of the topfive owners of u. He also strongly rejected the patent troll moniker, when. Npr showed youre a patent troll, get over it by matt levy june 3, 20 this post is the latest in the dear intellectual ventures series. Intellectual ventures sets up isf incubator to commercialize. A lawsuit brought by the worlds largest patent troll, intellectual ventures, and handled on appeal as are all patent cases, by the notoriously awful court of appeals for the federal circuit. Microsoft is trying to patent software in india while microsofts proxy troll intellectual ventures extorts motorola android 2014. Intellectual ventures stops buying patents patentlyo. Intellectual ventures, which has been accused of being the worlds biggest patent troll, has ramped up its lobbying as congress works on legislation to curb abusive patent lawsuits. Patent trolls use a number of legal activities that.
The impolite word for companies who use patents this way, rather than in the course of making and selling products, is patent troll. It was clear after one search that they were a patent troll but uncovering the true identities of people involved in the suite was time. The article raises some very thoughtprovoking questions about software patents and whether or not these patents are realizing the original goals of the patent system in promoting innovation. Aug 21, 2012 nathan myhrvold intellectual ventures. The investigation takes them to a small town in texas, where they find a hallway full of empty companies with no employees. Who are the most wellknown andor prolific patent trolls. Predatory litigation and the smothering of innovation, william j. Mar 31, 2016 when it comes to patent trolls, no one is bigger than intellectual ventures. But ive come to realize that patent protection is at best no. Rothschild by a wide margin to become the years most active socalled patent troll. Original patent troll law firm is shutting down ars. The best resrource for information about patent troll activity, in my view, is patent freedom. Nathan myhrvold, founder and chief executive office of intellectual ventures and primary author of the modernist cuisine books, speaks.
When it comes to patent trolls, no one is bigger than intellectual ventures. Patent trolls hit with a onetwo punch entrepreneur. Intellectual ventures now owns over 80,000 patents and pending patent applications. Aug 19, 2014 intellectual ventures, the company silicon valley loves to despise, is laying off about 20 percent of its employees, bloomberg businessweek has learned. Using overbroad patents based on dated technology, trolls threaten litigation and bring infringement suits against inventors. Gao report unmasks the mythical patent troll problem. Inside intellectual ventures, the most hated company in tech. World patent marketing supports inventors by fighting patent. In a company post, plainsite said it uncovered the list through the united states.
Patent troll, pejorative term for a company, found most often in the american information technology industry, that uses a portfolio of patents not to produce products but solely to collect licensing fees or. A piece of software was more like a book or an article. Though it claims to promote innovation, intellectual ventures is behind some of the most outrageous troll. Microsofts patent troll intellectual ventures is collapsing as 20% of staff laid off. Heres how one startup fought back when fitnessring maker motiv got a threat from mhm, it went. Feb 21, 2014 intellectual ventures starts pac to lobby for patent trolls. Myhrvold has described his goal for intellectual ventures as helping to create a market for patentbacked securities. Led by prolific inventor and visionary nathan myhrvold, iv has created more than a dozen companies with the power to transform industries. Nathan paul myhrvold born august 3, 1959, formerly chief technology officer at microsoft, is cofounder of intellectual ventures and the principal author of modernist cuisine and its successor books. Our guides this hour are going to be npr correspondent laura sydell and this.
Patent troll sues basically anyone who notifies you when your package ships. Planet money why would a company rent an office in a tiny town in east texas, put a nameplate on the door, and leave it. Mar 09, 2017 lose some, lose some appeals court throws out six intellectual ventures do it on a computer patents massive patent holder has been suing for years now, but it cant win a case. Back in 2011, i put the question of whether or not intellectual ventures is a patent troll to its cofounder nathan.
Cnet went behind the scenes to understand what 40,000 patents and an unapologetic plan to make money from them really means. The washington statebased behemoth is at the center of both patent trolling and the debate around. The influential blog techdirt regularly refers to intellectual ventures as a patent troll. Jul 22, 2011 intellectual ventures and the war over software patents. Tweet share post its been a good year for patent trolls, and now the biggest troll of them all wants to keep the party going. The washington statebased behemoth is at the center of both patent trolling and the debate around patent reform. This american lifes alex blumberg and nprs laura sydell have been digging into the. Accused patent troll intellectual ventures ramps up lobbying. Volumes of patent decisions from the official gazette of the u. Feb 11, 2015 intellectual ventures has filed legal action against more than 30 companies since it started using its patent portfolio to sue for infringement in 2010. The term patent troll was used at least once in 1993, albeit with a slightly different meaning, to describe countries that file aggressive patent lawsuits.
Its business model has a focus on buying patents and aggregating them into a large patent portfolio and licensing these patents to third. It owns patent portfolios as well as supplies inventions to innovative companies through various licensing and partnering programs. At that time fat was the enemy, and her invention languished. I would not consider rpx or ocean tomo as patent trolls. Intellectual ventures is a global invention and investment business that creates, incubates, and commercializes inventions. Another blog, ipwatchdog, called intellectual ventures patent troll public. A patent troll by any other name still stinks readwrite. Intellectual ventures is secretive about how it works. Intellectual ventures and the war over software patents. A more accurate title might be this american knife. To me, its a little bit like saying, well, if you built your house, you. Patent troll intellectual ventures is more like a hydra the. Jul 22, 2011 npr reporter laura sydell and this american life producerplanet money cohost alex blumberg tell the story of intellectual ventures, which is accused of being the largest of the patent trolls. Bill gates pet troll intellectual ventures is collapsing as founder quits.
The current patent system can severely hamper the growth of software startups here in the u. Intellectual ventures starts pac to lobby for patent trolls. Thats because trolls are filing an unprecedented number of expensive lawsuits. Npr reporter laura sydell and this american life producerplanet money cohost alex blumberg tell the story of intellectual ventures, which is accused of being the largest of the patent trolls. A growing number are banding together to defend themselves. Jul 17, 2014 tweet share post its been a good year for patent trolls, and now the biggest troll of them all wants to keep the party going. Intellectual ventures basically defines this invention gap as the number of patents that a company is infringing when it makes or sells its products. Suffice to say, intellectual ventures is, in the minds of many, the worlds biggest patent troll, waiting to demand a fee for what you were sure was an. After describing recent trends and efforts to tame the trolls, watkins focuses on. After we were sued by blackbird, we decided that we wouldnt roll. Taking the battle against patent trolls to the public.
How hightech banks are fighting back against patent trolls american banker. Intellectual ventures cofounder peter detkin joins sherpa. Startups arent typically founded by lawyers, so patent law isnt usually a front line issue for them. But here is the headline for quinns blog post last week.
Patent system is supposed to represent a bargain between inventors and the public. My guest tonight has written a sixvolume book on cuttingedge food made with. The company is one of the most notorious patent trolls. Appeals court throws out six intellectual ventures do it on. Jan 09, 2017 leading advisory firm sherpa technology group today announced the appointment of peter detkin, a pioneer in the field of technology and intellectual property ip strategy, to the role of. Patent troll sues basically anyone who notifies you when. This interesting comment in the npr piece indicates detkins attempt to avoid his own. All tech considered radio and print ads launched this week warn of damage wrought by socalled patent trolls.
Inside intellectual ventures, the most hated company in. Who does patenttrading firm intellectual ventures work for. Famous patent troll intellectual ventures only owns somewhere in the range of to 5000 patents. I worked at intellectual ventures fulltime for more than a year pros nathan myhrvold is a fantastic innovator, philanthropist, and creative, working at iv is an opportunity to observe a truly unique leader with unusual interests, motivators and drive. Removal of this dedicated capital from the market likely means a continued depression of patent prices especially for patents not directly tied to a product currently on the market.
Intellectual ventures is engaged in the business of invention. Patent trolls are killing startups except when theyre. Intellectual ventures comes to india and no its not a big. Upon knowing that you or your business are being targetted by a patent troll, you should immediately contact an experienced patent attorney to lay out a plan of action on how to deal with the. Patents and trademarks patent trolls target small businesses with lawsuit threats. The term patent troll generally refers to patent owners that do not make or sell products, and instead focus on licensing and litigation to monetize their acquired patents. Executives at intellectual ventures insist they are not trolls, but rather, promoters of innovation. Sep 04, 2014 holma, an animalnutrition expert, had 20 years earlier developed a cow feed that increased the fat content of their milk. Unfortunately, there is really no universally accepted definition of what a patent troll is, which has lead myself and others to recognize that by and large if you are being sued for patent. Sep 19, 2017 intellectual ventures is launching a new unit called isf incubator to match up its inventions with entrepreneurs who can turn them into businesses. Planet money in 2011, a company called oasis research sued more than a dozen tech companies it said were violating its patent for online data backup. Sep 16, 2018 founded in 2000, intellectual ventures has earned a special brand of hatred in the business world as the ultimate patent troll. The episode couldnt be more timely, with patent troll legislation being considered in congress. At the center of the patent troll controversy is the founder and ceo of the company nathan myhrvold.
The supreme courts big ruling on patent trolls will. Intellectual ventures shows patenttrolllike ambitions. Intellectual ventures is an american private company that centers on the development and licensing of intellectual property. Patent troll intellectual ventures faces off against moto. If intellectual ventures patent defines a software update tool in terms that dont match motorola. Intellectual ventures and its 80,000 patents patentlyo. Our portfolio company cloudflare posted yesterday about the two and a half year war it waged against a patent troll called blackbird. Appeals court throws out six intellectual ventures do it. This was the battle plan that cloudflare came up with. Founded in 2000, intellectual ventures has earned a special brand of hatred in the business world as the ultimate patent troll. A patent troll is a derogatory term used to describe the use of patent infringement claims to win court judgments for profit or to stifle competition. The episode couldnt be more timely, with patent troll legislation. Intellectual ventures acquires hundreds of patents for new.
Intellectual ventures has stopped buying patents on the secondary market based upon an investor driven decision. Intellectual ventures is considered the biggest troll of them all, with 15,000 20,000 patents held. For example the bs published latha jishnus views on the mou between intellectual ventures and iitb under the title hope is a patent troll for iitbombay. The most active patent trolls of 2016 industries targeted. Mar 16, 2015 doover patent troll intellectual ventures faces off against moto jury will decide the case at a time of intense debate around patents. Patent trolls target small businesses with lawsuit threats. Original patent troll law firm is shutting down the niro firm made tech companies shudder and made a few inventors wealthy. But former colleagues of myhrvold and patent experts watching moves at intellectual ventures say the firm is less an invention company than a protection company.
Aug 24, 2017 contrast this with a new hours old article about another microsoftconnected patent troll, intellectual ventures. This weekend, this american life aired the follow up to when patents attack. Patent trolls are currently under intense scrutiny by lawmakers, regulators, academics, and industry players. The patent troll crisis is really a software patent crisis.
1499 212 632 820 1394 588 13 88 1439 1515 252 1311 1159 323 454 105 482 206 475 780 824 167 36 1567 723 196 186 1273 287 1165 1472 1322 1368